Igor Volsky
Marist College
Giuliani Ramps Up Iran Hawkishness, Hires Neo Con Michael Rubin

giuliani1.jpgYesterday, The Body Politik noted that while former New York City mayor Rudy Giuliani portrays himself as an expert on terrorism, his actual statements and policy judgments usually reveal his ignorance. Today, Josh Marshall notes that Rudy Giuliani has hired “Michael Rubin as Senior Iran and Turkey Advisor and Middle East Advisory Board Member.”

Rubin worked at “Doug Feith’s Office of Special Plans” and “like the most interesting and frightening neos, Michael is that perfect mix of extreme factual knowledge and extreme lack of judgment, prone to wild-eyed theories and fantasies of various sorts but all in the end leading inexorably toward catastrophic policy moves for the United States.” Below is a sampling of Rubin’s greatest hits:

- IRAQ: “The question with Iraq is not whether they were involved on Sept. 11. The question with Iraq is, do we think they have the capacity, the will and the means to create mass casualties in the United States. I think they do. The evidence shows they do. And then the issue is, why should we wait and sacrifice another 5,000 innocent lives?” [10/24/01 Yale Daily News]

- “September 11 has helped to persuade the region that the United States isn’t going to take it anymore. Even onerous regimes are eager or willing to be part of the U.S. coalition against Usama bin Ladin’s terrorism. Under resolute U.S. leadership, some of this spirit could be mobilized against Iraq.… [Ankara, Amman, Kuwait City, and Riyadh] want to see a plan that is focused, determined, and close-ended. If the United States can produce one, its regional allies will fall into line.”[Winter/02, Middle East Quarterly]

- “The Kurds themselves, many of them patriotic veterans of the Iraqi Army do not wish to split from Iraq; they do want a federal, unified and democratic Iraq. Their only problem is with Saddam Husayn himself. Until he is removed, nothing can proceed.” [ 7/10/01, Middle East Forum]

- The New York Times reports that Rubin advised The Lincoln Group, a Pentagon contractor that paid Iraqi newspapers to print American propaganda, on the content of the propaganda campaign in Iraq. [1/2/06, NYT]

- IRAN: “U.S. and Iranian interests in Iraq are diametrically opposed, and will continue to be until one side wins and the other loses.” Diplomacy with Iran is “a mirage, a tactical tool to divert U.S. policy attention away from the Revolutionary Guards and intelligence officials charged with implementing the Iranian leadership’s objectives…For the U.S. government to succeed in Iraq, it must engage not with the illusion of Iranian policy, but refine its strategies to neutralize and counter the Iranian strategies.” [8/09/07, Washington Post]

- “In the wake of Sadr’s uprising, Washington is faced with the same choice: End Iran’s infiltration through forceful action, or wish it away. How long can we afford to keep choosing the latter? [4/26/04, New Republic]

- ISLAMIC WORLD: “In the Islamic world, confrontation may work better than dialogue. As the Taliban were driven from Kabul, Afghans spontaneously celebrated, cheering America in the streets…Washington should not negotiate with rogue regimes, at least not until they move beyond mere rhetoric and unilaterally cease all weapons proliferation and terror sponsorship without precondition.” [12/12/01, Opinion Journal]

- REGIME CHANGE IN SYRIA: The Asia Times reported that Michael Rubin and the usual neo-con suspects “signed a report released three years ago that called for using military force to disarm Syria of weapons of mass destruction (WMD) and to end its military presence in Lebanon.” [4/17/03, Asia Times]

By recruiting hard line neo-conservatives, Giuliani is tacitly endorsing the failed foreign policy of the Bush administration. If the war on terror and the war in Iraq have radicalized jihadists and increased the terror threat, Giuliani’s willingness to pursue a confrontational and militant foreign policy– possibly extending the war to Iran– would jeopardize American safety and security.

Comments (12)

Giuliani Ramps Up Iran Hawkishness, Hires Neo Con Michael Rubin…

This story has been submitted to Stirrdup. Your support can help it become hot….

Bob

How do you radicalize a Jihadist? By definition, they already are. Such is the reasoning of Igor.

Regardless, with the exception of Iraq, I find nothing objectionable about the rest of his statements.

The American government paid someone to print pro-American propganda? The horror!

The last quote is simply strange. Syria has long been known to have chemical weapons, and Israel reportedly destroyed a nascent nuclear weapons facility a few weeks ago.

Nate

Bob: Muslim and Jihadist are two separate terms. Your flippant attitude toward the effects of US foreign policy, particularly the fact that we subverted the press in a country we are supposedly “introducing to democracy” is appalling. Secretly paying foreign press to print US propaganda is NOT ok! Implying that an entire religion is crazy is also not ok. Our policy about nuclear weapons is hypocritical and ultimately little more than an excuse to invade countries which have things we want. If nuclear weapons are so bad, then will we support Syria when they go in and take out Israel’s nuclear facilities? What about Pakistan and India, should we bomb them to the stone age because they have nukes? Do you even realize the incredible double standards and hypocracy of your arguments?

Louis

Bob

pwnt

end

Matt

Point Nate - Bob question: why do you think America should dictate other sovereign nations? Are we not as bad as the dictators that rule those nations when we do this?

kevin

Its not acting like a wild west cowboy. These are soverign nations. Anytime you go there, you are OCCUPIERS. It naturally creates a revolution and many young US soldiers die.

So bring the draft. This is the only way to tone down the neo cons.

Draft jenna bush first.

[…] fact, by dismissing the science that contradicts his new-found ideology, Romney, like Rudy, is following in the footsteps of our current […]

[…] than any of them the consequences of Islamic radicalism, has chosen foreign policy advisers like Michael Rubin, one of the geniuses behind the Iraq debacle, and Norman Podhoretz, who is distinguishing himself […]

Jerry Alexander

Go Ron Paul!!!

Leave a Reply